If Aristotle Ran Hogwarts: Unlocking the Philosophical Depths of Popular Culture

Throughout history, philosophers have grappled with the complexities of life, morality, and human existence. However, rarely do we associate these deep thinkers with the magical world of Harry Potter. If Aristotle were to take charge at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, how would his philosophical teachings shape the popular culture phenomenon we know and love today?

The Rationality of Aristotle and the Founding Principles of Hogwarts

In the Harry Potter series, Hogwarts is portrayed as a school of magic where young witches and wizards learn to harness their magical abilities. The core principles of the school, such as courage, knowledge, and loyalty, align with Aristotle's philosophy of virtue ethics.

Aristotle believed that individuals could achieve true happiness, or eudaimonia, by living a life of virtue. Virtue, according to Aristotle, involves finding the right balance between extremes. For example, in the Harry Potter world, courage, represented by Gryffindor house, lies between recklessness and cowardice.

Harry Potter and Philosophy: If Aristotle Ran Hogwarts (Popular Culture and Philosophy Book 9)

by William Irwin (Kindle Edition)

4.4 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	808 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	260 pages

FREE

Each Hogwarts house embodies specific virtues and vices. Gryffindor emphasizes bravery, Hufflepuff promotes loyalty, Ravenclaw values intelligence, and Slytherin is known for its ambition. Aristotle's influence would only strengthen the connection between these virtues and the house sorting process, as students would be encouraged to strive for moral excellence in all areas of their lives.

Muggle Studies and Examining Prejudices

One of the lesser-discussed subjects at Hogwarts is Muggle Studies. In the Harry Potter series, this course focuses on educating wizarding students about non-magical people, known as Muggles. If Aristotle were to run Hogwarts, he would likely approach this subject from a philosophical standpoint. Muggle Studies would delve into the concept of prejudice and explore how biases affect our judgment of others.

Aristotle's teachings on ethics encourage individuals to cultivate moral virtues, including fairness, empathy, and justice. By incorporating these principles into Muggle Studies, students would gain a better understanding of the importance of equality and combat discriminatory tendencies, ultimately fostering a more inclusive and accepting society.

The Ethics of Love Potions: Aristotle's Perspective

In the wizarding world, love potions exist, allowing individuals to manipulate someone's feelings and desires. However, these potions raise ethical concerns about free will, consent, and the genuine nature of love. If Aristotle were to have a say, he would undoubtedly argue against the use of love potions.

For Aristotle, genuine love involves the mutual cultivation of virtues between individuals. By using love potions, people manipulate their desired outcomes rather than fostering a genuine connection. Aristotle would insist on the importance of consent, arguing that true love should be rooted in a reciprocal relationship where both individuals actively choose to show virtuous qualities to one another.

The Role of Friendship and Aristotelian Bonds

The bonds of friendship play a significant role in the Harry Potter series, with characters relying on each other for support, guidance, and loyalty. Aristotle saw friendship as an essential aspect of a virtuous life, believing that true friends enrich one another morally.

If Aristotle ran Hogwarts, he would emphasize the importance of building strong friendships and fostering bonds based on shared virtues. Students would be encouraged to seek friends who display qualities they admire and would strive to develop those virtues within themselves.

Magic, Knowledge, and Wisdom

In the wizarding world, knowledge of magical spells and potions is highly valued. However, Aristotle would argue that true wisdom goes beyond memorizing incantations. He believed that wisdom is the culmination of both theoretical and practical knowledge, leading individuals to live a life of virtue and moral excellence.

If Aristotle were in charge of Hogwarts, he would emphasize the importance of knowledge for virtuous action. Magic would be taught alongside philosophical teachings, encouraging students to question the nature of power, responsibility, and the ethical implications of their magical abilities.

: The Aesthetic of Wisdom in the Wizarding World

The integration of Aristotle's philosophy into the magical world of Harry Potter would deepen the exploration of morals, ethics, and the human experience. By weaving philosophical concepts into the narrative, the Harry Potter series would become more than just a popular culture phenomenon; it would become a gateway to timeless wisdom.

If Aristotle ran Hogwarts, students would not only learn to be skilled wizards and witches but also cultivate an understanding of virtue ethics, empathy, and the complexities of human relationships. The influence of Aristotle would elevate the series beyond mere entertainment, offering a profound reflection on the profound questions that have fascinated philosophers for centuries.

Harry Potter and Philosophy: If Aristotle Ran Hogwarts (Popular Culture and Philosophy Book 9)

by William Irwin (Kindle Edition)

4.4 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	808 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	260 pages

FREE

In Harry Potter and Philosophy, seventeen philosophical experts unlock some of Hogwarts' secret panels, and uncover surprising insights that are enlightening both for wizards and the most discerning muggles.